If the poster did not tip you off then, you definitively do not have what it takes to be a detective =P
Well to get to the point, I managed to catch the latest flick hitting the big screens, Sherlock Holmes on the last day of 2009. This was one movie that I had actually been anticipating for the duration of 2009. The reason being that I am an avid fan of the Sherlock Holmes novels written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, and having read the compendium of all stories about S.H, I was looking forward to a LOTR-esque novel to big screen adaptation of one of the major cases in the novel.
I was disappointed by the latter. The movie was not an adaptation but a fictional tale conjured by the magicians in Hollywood with our hero S.H in place. I cringed when I realized that the beloved detective would not be able to enthrall us with his deductive logic in one of the riveting cases in the novel such as the. A Study In Scarlet or The Hound of the Baskervilles’.
Robert Downey Jr was cast as S.H and while he did play the role with a flair, I cannot help but comment that S.H was described as a lanky man as well one who uses surprise and brilliant deductive logic to awe his clients as he solves their cases. Frankly in the movie, S.H comes off as a showy, over dramatic man. Watson too was more than the quiet contemplative doctor portrayed in the novel, but more like S.H’s partner in crime, taking on a much larger role and vocal role, with a bad habit of gambling and brawling.
The insertion of certain characters from the novel into different roles in the movie irked me. Irene Adler, the one woman who had bested S.H twice in the novel was cast as his criminal linked, love interest/lover. Where in the novel Holmes showed admiration for her ability to deceive him, in the movie it is love.
Mary Morstan, the love interest and soon-to-be wife of James Watson M.D, was central to one of S.H first cases that would establish him in the detective business, was a total stranger to him in the movie…
The biggest plot twist was near the end where the producers tried to squeeze a sequel out of the movie by introducing Professor Moriaty, the arch-nemesis of S.H. I should add here that in the novels, Moriaty never dirtied his fingers by ever showing that he was associated with the criminal underworld, let alone carrying weapons =.=^ He was the main puppeteer behind the London crime society and the intellectual equal of Holmes.
This movie may have been ruined for me because of my having read the novel beforehand.
To those unacquainted with the books, this movie would probably rivet you to your seats! Enjoy!!